Maggies Original Cookie Co Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Maggies Original Cookie Co, a delightful bakery nestled in the heart of Conway, Arkansas. Known for its mouthwatering assortment of cookies and decadent brownies, this charming establishment is a community favorite. Every treat is crafted with care, ensuring that each bite melts in your mouth, just as our customers rave about.
- Celebration Trays: Perfect for gatherings, offering options ranging from 3.5 to 8.0 dozen cookies, allowing you to savor an array of flavors.
- Big Cookies: Indulge in gourmet delights, baked fresh to order, each cookie promises a comforting, homemade experience.
- Traditional Treats: Explore a menu filled with classics like the Snickerdoodle and Peanut Butter Kiss Cookie, all for just $1.00 each.
Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply craving something sweet, Maggies Original Cookie Co is sure to exceed your expectations and become your go-to cookie haven!
Big Cookies
Traditional Treats Big Cookies
Big Cookies need a minimum of 1 1/2 hours for order to be baked and decorated for delivery.
Gourmet Delights Big Cookies
Big Cookies need a minimum of 1 1/2 hours for order to be baked and decorated for delivery!
3.5 Dozen Tray
Small tray with 42 favorites
4.5 Dozen Tray
Small tray with 54 favorites
6.5 Dozen Tray
Large tray with 78 favorites
7.5 Dozen Tray
Large tray with 90 favorites
8.0 Dozen Tray
Large tray with 96 favorites
Celebration Trays
Traditional Treats
Chocolate Chip
Just like your momma's... Only better
Coconut Macaroons
Better than the classic!
Kiss Cookie
Up for peanut butter and chocolate
M&m Cookie
Melts in your mouth not in your hands
Maggie's Mistakes
One of maggie's best mistakes by far
Mexican Wedding
Pecan sandie dusted with powdered sugar
Oatmeal Raisin
This classic needs no introduction
Peanut Butter
Peter pan never had it so good
Raspberry Thumbprint
Personalized shortbread
Sand Tart
The beach isn't any better
Snickerdoodle
Yummy name, better to eat
Sugar Cookie
Melts in your mouth not in your hands
Butterfinger
Don't lose a finger on the butterfinger cookie
Candy Bar
Two desserts in one
Gourmet Chocolate Chip
The ultimate chocolate chip cookie
No Bakes
You'll never no-bake them again
Nutty Chocolate Chip
Sometimes you just feel like a nut
Peanut Butter Chunk
Big chunks of heaven
Peanut Butter No Bakes
Maggie's original recipe
Smiley Face Cookie
Guaranteed to brighten anyone's day
Gourmet Delights
Bars & Brownies
Magic Cookie Bar
An incredible disappearing act
Rocky Road
These will make the journey smoother
Lemon Bar
Luscious lemon with cream cheese
German Chocolate
Yummy combo of chocolate and caramel
Cream Cheese Brownie
For chocolate addicts only
Fudge Brownie
Nothin plain about this brownie