Welcome to Maggies Original Cookie Co, where every cookie feels like a warm hug from your childhood. Nestled in the heart of Conway, Arkansas, this charming bakery has become a beloved haven for cookie enthusiasts and dessert lovers alike. Located at 2850 Prince St #17, Maggie's offers a delightful array of traditional treats that have been crafted with love and precision, ensuring every bite is a moment of bliss.

As soon as you step inside, the enticing aroma of freshly baked cookies fills the air, luring you into a world of sweet indulgence. Each treat is meticulously prepared, from the classic Oatmeal Raisin that needs no introduction, to the renowned Chocolate Chip cookie, which elevates nostalgia to a new level of deliciousness. You might also find the Sugar Cookie that truly melts in your mouth, and the Coconut Macaroons, which are better than the classics—yes, you read that right!

• Maggie's Mistakes: A deliciously charming reminder that some blunders turn into the best treats.
• Mexican Wedding Cookies: These pecan sandies, lightly dusted with powdered sugar, bring a hint of celebration to your palate.
• Kiss Cookie: A delightful combo of peanut butter and chocolate that’s sure to please.

Whether you’re in the mood for a quick treat or looking to cater a party, Maggie’s has you covered with their Celebration Trays. Ranging from large trays with up to 96 cookies to smaller selections with 42 favorites, each tray can be customized to suit your needs, making it an excellent choice for gatherings, birthdays, and special occasions.

From customer reviews, it’s clear that Maggie's Original Cookie Co has captured the hearts and taste buds of many in Conway. Patrons rave about the quick and friendly service, the homemade quality, and especially the custom cookie designs. One happy customer, Jenn M., shared how Maggie's unique tooth-shaped cookies made her graduation dinner extra special. Another patron, Melissa P., fondly recalls the perfect sugar cookies, which she has even had shipped across state lines, arriving fresh and delicious.

Maggies Original Cookie Co is not just a bakery; it is a memorable experience filled with flavor, creativity, and community spirit. Whether you’re picking up a sweet gift or treating yourself after a long day, Maggie’s should undoubtedly be your first stop in Conway. Come indulge in the magic of their cookies, where every bite is made with passion and a little sprinkle of fun!